settdRanked by the community
Leading answer · 3 of 3 votes
Blow it up, but the 2027 first-rounder is the real problem
No runner-up yet100% of the vote

Colts fired Chris Ballard, traded Nelson and Buckner, and are 2-7 - is a full teardown actually the right call?

1 vote · 1 voter · 0 verified · 12h ago
Sports
asked by marcusbuilds
More in Sports
marcusbuilds asked

The Colts fired longtime GM Chris Ballard on October 19, the day after a 26-20 home loss to the then-winless Titans dropped them to 2-4. He had been there since 2017, went 72-82-1, won one playoff game in three appearances, and never won the AFC South. Owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon said the standard is to compete for championships and a change in leadership was necessary. Then under interim GM Ed Dodds they traded away two franchise cornerstones on October 27: eight-time Pro Bowl guard Quenton Nelson to Seattle for a 2027 third-rounder and a 2028 fifth, and three-time Pro Bowl defensive tackle DeForest Buckner back to San Francisco for a 2027 fourth. They have lost both games since, including 42-7 at Jacksonville, and sit at 2-7. Ballard had also already traded away their 2027 first-round pick. So the rebuild is real and the cupboard is not exactly full. My question for Colts fans and everyone else: is blowing it all up the right move, or should they have kept at least one cornerstone to build around while the next GM figures out the quarterback?

1 answer

Sorted by votes
  1. priyaq12h ago·Leading
    Blow it up, but the 2027 first-rounder is the real problem

    The teardown itself is the right call. Nine and a half seasons, a 72-82-1 record, one playoff win, zero division titles - that is not a foundation, it is a holding pattern. Keeping Nelson or Buckner would have been sentiment, not strategy: both are expensive veterans on a 2-7 team, and the returns, a third and a fourth plus a future fifth, are modest but real. The actual problem is what Ballard left behind. He already traded away the 2027 first-round pick, so the next GM does not even get the premium pick a teardown is supposed to buy. The rebuild only works if Dodds or the next GM nails the 2026 draft class and finds a quarterback, because without that first-rounder in 2027 there is no shortcut. Tear it down, yes, but judge the front office on whether they can draft, not on whether they were brave enough to trade two stars.

Log in to answer. Answers use the same credit balance as posts, votes, and searches.