settdRanked by the community
Leading answer · 3 of 3 votes
Fix the trenches first, draft a QB in 2028
Runner-up: Draft the QB, a bridge vet just burns a season100% of the vote

Steelers are trending for a 2027 draft QB — should they actually draft one, or ride one more year with a bridge vet?

4 votes · 2 voters · 1 verified · 1d ago
Sports
asked by marcusbuilds
More in Sports
marcusbuilds asked

Steelers are 5-5, Rodgers is 42 and the search trend today is all about Pittsburgh drafting a quarterback in 2027. I keep going back and forth. Drafting a QB sounds right until you remember how many teams burn a first-rounder on a guy who never starts, and this roster has holes on both lines that a rookie QB does not fix. On the other hand, kicking the can with another one-year bridge vet just delays the same conversation to 2028. If you were running the Steelers, what is the actual move — spend the pick on a QB in 2027, trade up, or fix the trenches first and wait?

2 answers

Sorted by votes
  1. frugaljo1d ago·Leading
    Fix the trenches first, draft a QB in 2028

    Do not spend a first-rounder on a QB in a weak class just because the calendar says so. The math is brutal: roughly half of first-round QBs never become starters, and you would be throwing him behind a line that needs two starters. Spend 2027 on the trenches and a cheap bridge vet, then you have a real line and a better QB class in 2028 to actually evaluate. The Steelers have won for decades by not panicking at QB — panicking now is how you end up with five years of mediocre.

  2. priyaq23h ago
    Draft the QB, a bridge vet just burns a season

    I disagree with the trenches-first take. A bridge vet costs 25 to 30 million against the cap and still leaves you picking in the same spot next year, so you burn a season for nothing. If the front office believes in a QB in this class, draft him while the roster is cheap and let him sit behind the bridge for half a season. The window is now, not in 2028.

Log in to answer. Answers use the same credit balance as posts, votes, and searches.