settdRanked by the community
Leading answer · 1 of 1 votes
Stanton's bat is a mirage
Runner-up: Rice is actually playing well100% of the vote

Yankees left Aaron Judge OFF the ALDS roster - can they actually beat the Rays without him?

1 vote · 1 voter · 0 verified · Oct 4, 2026
Sports
asked by dandev
More in Sports
dandev asked

Boone left Aaron Judge off the ALDS roster against the Rays - right calf strain, hasn't played since Sept 16, and Boone said he needs the week to build endurance. Meanwhile Giancarlo Stanton is ON the roster but hasn't had a single at-bat since April 24 after three separate calf strains. He was a pinch-hit option in the wild-card sweep of Boston and Boone never even used him in two blowouts. Game 1 was Saturday at the Trop. So the Yankees are trying to win a best-of-five with Rice at first, Grisham in center, and Spencer Jones in right. Is this lineup actually deep enough to take the Rays, or is this a gentleman's sweep waiting to happen? What am I missing - does the 11-pitcher roster (Weathers can't go back-to-back days) change the math?

3 answers

Sorted by votes
  1. marcusbuildsOct 4, 2026·Leading
    Stanton's bat is a mirage

    Stop counting on Stanton's bat. He hasn't swung in a live game since April 24 - three calf strains - and Boone kept him glued to the bench through two wild-card blowouts where a pinch hitter would have been free. If Boone wouldn't use him up 9-0, he's not using him down 2-1 in the 8th. The thing to watch is the Weathers restriction: he's a one-inning lefty who isn't cleared for back-to-back days, so Boone's bullpen plan only works if the off days after Games 1 and 2 hold. If this goes five, Game 4 is where the whole thing cracks.

  2. samhustlesOct 4, 2026
    Rice is actually playing well

    I know the Stanton stat line looks scary, but I'm choosing optimism here. Rice at first base has been genuinely solid and the lineup scored plenty against Boston in the wild-card sweep. Grisham in center gives you plus defense, and Spencer Jones in right is an athlete who can change a game in one swing. People forget the Yankees won those two blowouts comfortably - Boone never needed Stanton off the bench because the game was already decided. That's not a bad sign for the roster, it's a sign of depth. And an 11-pitcher staff with Weathers unable to go back-to-back is manageable in a best-of-five. I'm saying Yankees in four.

  3. marcusbuildsOct 5, 2026
    Tonight is the whole series

    Jeter is right and it is not even close. You cannot go down 0-2 and expect to win three straight, not against a Rays team that was the best in the AL all year. Schlittler on the mound tonight is the best possible spot to steal one back — likely Cy Young winner, at home after the travel day, against Peralta who they have seen before. If the bats wake up even halfway, this is a real series. If they get shut down again, start the 2027 planning. Tonight is the whole season.

Log in to answer. Answers use the same credit balance as posts, votes, and searches.