Yankees left Aaron Judge OFF the ALDS roster - can they actually beat the Rays without him?
Boone left Aaron Judge off the ALDS roster against the Rays - right calf strain, hasn't played since Sept 16, and Boone said he needs the week to build endurance. Meanwhile Giancarlo Stanton is ON the roster but hasn't had a single at-bat since April 24 after three separate calf strains. He was a pinch-hit option in the wild-card sweep of Boston and Boone never even used him in two blowouts. Game 1 was Saturday at the Trop. So the Yankees are trying to win a best-of-five with Rice at first, Grisham in center, and Spencer Jones in right. Is this lineup actually deep enough to take the Rays, or is this a gentleman's sweep waiting to happen? What am I missing - does the 11-pitcher roster (Weathers can't go back-to-back days) change the math?
3 answers
- Stanton's bat is a mirage
Stop counting on Stanton's bat. He hasn't swung in a live game since April 24 - three calf strains - and Boone kept him glued to the bench through two wild-card blowouts where a pinch hitter would have been free. If Boone wouldn't use him up 9-0, he's not using him down 2-1 in the 8th. The thing to watch is the Weathers restriction: he's a one-inning lefty who isn't cleared for back-to-back days, so Boone's bullpen plan only works if the off days after Games 1 and 2 hold. If this goes five, Game 4 is where the whole thing cracks.
- Rice is actually playing well
I know the Stanton stat line looks scary, but I'm choosing optimism here. Rice at first base has been genuinely solid and the lineup scored plenty against Boston in the wild-card sweep. Grisham in center gives you plus defense, and Spencer Jones in right is an athlete who can change a game in one swing. People forget the Yankees won those two blowouts comfortably - Boone never needed Stanton off the bench because the game was already decided. That's not a bad sign for the roster, it's a sign of depth. And an 11-pitcher staff with Weathers unable to go back-to-back is manageable in a best-of-five. I'm saying Yankees in four.
- Tonight is the whole series
Jeter is right and it is not even close. You cannot go down 0-2 and expect to win three straight, not against a Rays team that was the best in the AL all year. Schlittler on the mound tonight is the best possible spot to steal one back — likely Cy Young winner, at home after the travel day, against Peralta who they have seen before. If the bats wake up even halfway, this is a real series. If they get shut down again, start the 2027 planning. Tonight is the whole season.