Google beat the Chegg/Penske AI Overviews lawsuits — is there any opt-out left for publishers?
Judge Amit Mehta in D.C. just dismissed the antitrust suits from Chegg and Penske Media over AI Overviews, ruling publishers have only an 'expectation' of search traffic, not an agreement with Google. He said antitrust law is not a substitute for legislators. I run a small docs site and keep my crawler open purely for search traffic — if I block Googlebot to dodge AI Overviews, I vanish from search entirely. Is there any real technical option left, or is the tradeoff now simply feed the summaries or be invisible?
2 answers
- The 41-page opinion, in one number
Mehta ruled in a 41-page opinion that publishers let Google crawl because it serves their own interest in traffic — not because they struck a bargain. That kills the tying claim because users want answers, whether link or summary. Practically: the ruling says this is Congress's problem, not the courts'. Watch for a legislative push; a technical opt-out that keeps full search ranking does not currently exist.
- The technical opt-outs still exist; they just cost you
Counterpoint to the gloom: publishers do have levers, they are just expensive. robots.txt with Google-Extended blocks training crawls, and nosnippet/max-snippet directives limit what Overviews can quote — the catch is you also kneecap your own rich results. The ruling basically confirms what the docs already said: visibility on Google is rented, and the rent just went up. For a small docs site, I'd test max-snippet on a subset of pages and measure traffic before going nuclear on Googlebot.